Aug 20, 2016

Tug of war between Rail Directorates delays Rail projects



Turf battles have erupted and delayed important railway projects, with the directorates charged with raising non-fare revenue and increasing train speeds working at cross-purposes, say officials. A project to redevelop 400 railway stations has been caught in the crossfire

New Delhi: When Railway minister Suresh Prabhu set up two new directorates within his ministry in May, this wasn’t what he had in mind.
Turf battles have erupted and delayed important railway projects, with the directorates charged with raising non-fare revenue and increasing train speeds working at cross-purposes, multiple officials said.

According to a railway board member, who spoke on condition of anonymity, a lot of projects are being delayed because of “overlapping of work” between old and new directorates. Railways has 42 directorates in all.

“None of the directorates wants to listen to the others and a tug-of-war has started in the rail ministry as the railway minister has asked all directorates to show revenue-based results,” the board member said, adding the railway board is finding it difficult to resolve the situation.

Railway Board chairman A.K. Mittal, however, said there is no such tug-of-war. “The jurisdictions are well-defined and no overlapping is being faced. Coordination and consultation is ensured wherever required,” he said.

A project to redevelop 400 railway stations has been caught in the crossfire. The non-fare revenue directorate wants to give advertising rights at stations to a third party claiming Railways can earn up to Rs. 10,000 crore via this method. However, the land and amenities directorate responsible for allotting station re-development work says if the advertising component is removed from the project, developers will be discouraged and the project will see a setback.

A land and amenities directorate official said on condition of anonymity, “Some infrastructure developers have threatened to drop out from the station redevelopment project if they are not given advertising rights, because they won’t be able to recover the investment from just exploiting the vacant space given to them. There has to be some additional source of income for such a big investment. Our estimate was revenue potential of around Rs.500-600 crore from advertising rights, but it comes with the advantage of station development.”

He added that an infrastructure developer is likely to factor in the aesthetics of where to display ads to maintain the overall look of the station. An entity solely focused on maximising ad revenue won’t, he said.

Another problem area is the idea of land monetization floated by the railway minister and now being implemented by the non-fare revenue directorate. The legal department has pointed out that railway land cannot be leased out for more than 45 years. The department states that a lease of 90 years or more is tantamount to a sale, and that Indian Railways cannot sell its land. However, the non-fare revenue directorate believes increasing the tenure of the lease is the best way to raise revenue for pending projects.

The non-fare revenue directorate’s data monetization project has also run into problems, with questions being raised around privacy. “During the time of booking tickets, people are asked for ID proof which can be PAN card, driver’s licence, Aadhar number or election card. A section of railway officials have expressed concerns on whether these details can be shared with a third party,” said a railway ministry official on condition of anonymity. He added that as a government department, “Indian Railways has to show some kind of discretion. Someone’s obsession with non-fare revenue cannot resolve financial crisis of railways.”

Meanwhile, the mobility directorate is discovering that there is a significant overlap between its responsibilities and those of the traffic directorate.

The mobility directorate’s focus is on identifying and prioritising corridors where speeds can be raised, setting timetables for freight trains, eliminating bottlenecks, monitoring the progress of capacity enhancement works, and tackling speed restrictions, asset failures and rolling stock issues which affect service speeds.

An official from the traffic directorate said on condition of anonymity, “The biggest issue cropping up between us is speed and laying of tracks. We know that it is very difficult to increase speed on Indian railway tracks even by 5-10 km/hour every year because of several reasons including there being no proper access-control. Despite all these facts, if you form a directorate to do this without correcting and investing in the infrastructure, it’s just a waste of time.”

 

NEXT POST

READ MORE -

Rail News - Public service (4206) Rail News - Public service (3663) Rail News - Rail Employee (2330) News - General (417) DIVISION - JABALPUR (357) Rail News - Rail Development (321) News - Spl Train (265) Rail News - Job - Career (207) DIVISION - BHOPAL (205) Rail news - Metro (195) Rail News - Circulars (144) DIVISION - HUBLI (136) DIVISION - MORADABAD (122) Office Order (105) DIVISION - ALLAHABAD (94) World Rail News (85) Rail news - Public Alert (82) News - Loco Pilot (77) Rail News - Rail Budget (69) HIGH SPEED RAIL (68) Rail News - 7th Pay Commission (67) Rail News - New Train (63) Improvement in Facilities (59) Accidents (58) Rail News - Railway Safety (58) Rail Development (55) Rail news - World Rail (49) Rail News - Tourism (39) Public Interest (37) Award (35) News- Railway Exam Result (35) Rail News - Freight Services (35) DIVISION - Delhi (34) Rail News - Sports (33) Trade Union (33) Bonus (PLB) (30) PIB (29) Bullet train (28) News - Railway Employee (28) new line (26) IRCTC (25) News - Dearness Allowance (24) Station Master (24) TATKAL TICKET (22) RPF / RPSF (21) Railway News - Metro (21) Complaint and Suggestions (20) Railway Pensioners (20) Mumbai local (19) News - Job - Career (19) Rail News - Security (19) Rail News - Special Train (19) News - Catering (18) Railway time table (17) News - New Tech (16) Circulars - Govt of India (15) Scam (15) ‘Premium’ Special Trains (15) Know About (14) Rail News - Railway Revenue (14) Rail news - Employment Notification (14) Railway Board (14) Railway News - Delhi Metro (14) Catering Related Complaints (13) Railway Joke (13) Freight Corridor (12) DIVISION - RAIPUR (11) Dedicated Freight Corridors (11) Indian Railway History (11) Rail News - Security (11) Rail Accidents (10) AISMA (9) News - Exam Result (9) Passenger Amenities (9) Rail News - New Rail Line (9) Railway pass (9) Budget (8) DIVISION - Ambala (8) Employee News (8) INCOME TAX (8) PHOTO (8) Premium Air-Conditioned (8) Public Grievances (8) World Rail - China (8) fares hikes (8) semi-high speed (8) Central Railway (7) Night Duty Allowance (7) Rail budget (7) online tickets (7) International Railway (6) Mono Rail (6) Mumbai Metro (6) News - Budget (6) Rail Fares (6) Railway Safety (6) Ticket Booking (6) Train Cancellation (6) World Rail - Japan (6) Zone - Western Railway (6) extra coaches (6) guard (6) Always Important (5) Children Education Allowance (5) Drinking Water (5) HELP (5) Holiday Trains (5) IRCON (5) LOCOMOTIVE (5) Rail History (5) Rail News - Business (5) booking counters (5) hi-tech (5) macp (5) AIR - RAIL (4) Coaches (4) Food plazas (4) IMPORTANT RULE (4) Mumbai (4) News - Railway Rule (4) RAIL TEL (4) Rail Neer (4) Rail News - Rules (4) Railway Minister (4) World Rail - Pakistan (4) Zone - South Central Railway (4) e-ticket booking (4) escalators (4) Booking - Parcel (3) CCTV (3) DOUBLE DECKER TRAIN (3) Electrification (3) Konkan railway (3) Leave Rule (3) Medical Allowance (3) Member Engineering (3) Modal Question Paper (3) News - Rail Road (3) News- Railway Exam (3) PASS (3) Question Bank (3) Rail News - China (3) Rail fare hike (3) Suvidha Train (3) TRANSFER POLICY (3) VAISHNO DEVI (3) new pension scheme (3) reservation (3) tatkal ticket (3) Booking - Luggage (2) D & A RULE (2) Extension of train services (2) Khumbn Mela (2) LDCE (2) MATHERAN (2) MOBILE APPS (2) Minister of State for Railways (2) National Rail Museum (2) News -World Film (2) OROP (2) Passenger Reservation System (2) Police help desk (2) Provident Fund interest (2) Rail News - Goods Train (2) Railway Protection Force (2) Railway Proud (2) Railway Stations (2) Retiring Rooms (2) Revenue earnings (2) South Eastern Railway (2) Zone - East Central Railway (2) Zone - N E RLY (2) Zone - Northern Railway (2) Zone - Southern Railway (2) railway station (2) ALER (1) Air Travel (1) DIVISION - CENTRAL RAILWAY (1) DIVISION - MADURAI (1) DIVISION - VIJAYWADA (1) Directory (1) Division - Rangia (1) FOOT OVER BRIDGE (1) FORMS (1) Government Railway Police (1) House Rent Allowance (1) Interesting Facts (1) JAIPUR (1) LARGESS (1) LONDON (1) Lifeline Express (1) MST (1) Measures Against Fire (1) Medical Care (1) Ministry of Railway (1) News - TV (1) Passenger Security (1) RDSO (1) Rail - Roko (1) Rail Bridges (1) Rail News - Privatization (1) Rail News - Bengali (1) Rail News - Consumer Forum (1) Rail Tariff (1) Rail Tenders (1) Rail e-tickets (1) Railway Act (1) Railway Quarter (1) Railway Week (1) Rath Yatra (1) Road over Bridges work (1) SCRA (1) SKY BUS (1) Sainagar Shirdi (1) Suburban trains (1) Swadeshi (1) TRAVELLING ALLOWANCE (1) Ticket Examiner Staff (1) Track Man (1) WhatsApp (1) World Rail - New York (1) World Rail - Russia (1) World Rail - USA (1) World Rail - Washington (1) Zone - E RLY (1) Zone - N C RLY (1) Zone - North Western Railway (1) Zone - Northeast Frontier Railway (1) Zone - S E Railway (1) fire-fighting equipment (1) mobile ticket booking (1) smart card (1) wagon factories (1)

Followers