Jul 11, 2017

Berth too high, platform too far: It’s time to refashion Indian Railways into a disabled friendly network

Life for persons with disabilities is not easy in any case. It becomes even more difficult when the environment is unsympathetic to their needs. Recent cases of wheelchair-bound para-athlete Suvarna Raj and 100% blind Vaibhav Shukla bring this out very vividly.

If Indian Railways (IR) had made a sincere effort to provide equal access to persons with disability as they are required to do by the 22-year-old Disabilities Act then Suvarna would not have had to sleep on the floor of the compartment and Vaibhav would not have missed his entrance examination at Delhi University.
IR could not provide Suvarna with a lower berth leaving her with no option but to sleep on the floor of the compartment and Vaibhav had to miss his train because no one would open the door of the compartment reserved for persons with disabilities.

Union railway minister Suresh Prabhu has made the customary refrain of ordering an enquiry into the occurrence. But the way IR functions it will in all likelihood limit the enquiry to the sequence of events that led to the incident, leaving the organisational factors and systemic failures that created the incident unrecognised and thus unaddressed.

On the 3rd of December 2015, Prime Minister Narendra Modi launched the Accessible India Campaign (Sugamya Bharat Abhiyan.) This campaign begins with the statement that for persons with disabilities universal accessibility is critical to gain equal opportunity and live independently and participate fully in all aspects of life in an inclusive society.

Targets were set for each sector. But even though the Disabilities Act 1995 and the recently enacted legislation which replaces it mandate that IR should make passenger compartments and stations disabled friendly, the IR targets only focus on railway station accessibility. The key issue of accessibility of passenger coaches on an equal basis, in particular for wheelchair users, was ignored.

With such an attitude it is unlikely anyone will see a disabled friendly, barrier free IR in the foreseeable future unless the railway minister takes it upon himself to bring about a change in the thinking, culture and the manner of everyday decision-making so it keeps the need of persons with disability in view.

Even though IR appears a monolithic organisation, in practice decision-making is spread over numerous departments so the responsibility for building various links of the disability chain is also distributed, which makes creating a barrier free environment the responsibility of everyone and no one in particular.

Further, most of the railway stations and other infrastructure were built in the 19th or early 20th centuries, which makes it difficult to render them disabled friendly without substantial rebuilding, at great cost. To emphasise, moving from one platform to the other is also an issue as is accessibility to the compartments.

These are not problems peculiar to IR. European railways have addressed them by training handlers, constructing ramps to the extent possible and using mechanical devices to lift the wheelchair user into the compartment. Wheelchair users are asked if they would need any assistance when booking a ticket, which is provided by the railway as necessary.

IR also has to find the solutions. I would like to propose a doable solution based on my knowledge of IR as an ex-railwayman and as someone who is also a wheelchair user who travelled extensively by train for performing his duties. The proposed solution has three components. The first component is availability of assistance at embarking and destination stations very similar to what airlines provide.

The second component is that those assigned to assist including the coach attendants are adequately trained in handling wheelchairs and transferring a person with disability into an aisle chair, without injury. They also have to be capable of lifting the person into the compartment and settling him or her into the allotted chair or berth.

The last component is the ability of persons with disability to indicate their needs for assistance at the time of booking and an institutional mechanism that ensures that the asked-for assistance is provided when the passenger reports to the assistance desk.

Once this is put in place it has to be built upon by providing ramps and lifts that will enable persons with disabilities get to other platforms with ease. There is also a need for compartments with wider doors and accessible toilets and chairlifts for getting into compartments. Handlers will still be required but handling will become easier for them and safer for the persons with disabilities.

All this can only come about if the railway minister makes it his personal mission. For example he can make it clear that he will not inaugurate any facility or train that does not cater to the needs of persons with disabilities. For this he will need a disability adviser who acts as his ears and eyes, for assessing different facilities for compliance with disability requirements, before the minister accepts any invitation for inauguration.

The disabilities cell in his office will monitor the various projects for making infrastructure and coaches disabled friendly and for training station staff and coach attendants to handle wheelchairs, and also monitor the associated information systems and the institutional mechanisms for implementing the proposed three component system.





Rail News - Public service (4203) Rail News - Public service (3553) Rail News - Rail Employee (2328) DIVISION - JABALPUR (357) Rail News - Rail Development (318) News - General (299) News - Spl Train (263) Rail News - Job - Career (205) DIVISION - BHOPAL (203) Rail news - Metro (194) Rail News - Circulars (138) DIVISION - HUBLI (130) DIVISION - MORADABAD (122) Office Order (105) DIVISION - ALLAHABAD (93) World Rail News (85) Rail news - Public Alert (79) News - Loco Pilot (75) Rail News - Rail Budget (69) HIGH SPEED RAIL (68) Rail News - 7th Pay Commission (63) Rail News - New Train (62) Improvement in Facilities (58) Rail News - Railway Safety (58) Accidents (55) Rail Development (55) Rail news - World Rail (49) Rail News - Tourism (38) Award (35) News- Railway Exam Result (35) Rail News - Freight Services (35) DIVISION - Delhi (34) Public Interest (34) Trade Union (33) Rail News - Sports (32) Bonus (PLB) (30) PIB (29) Bullet train (28) new line (26) IRCTC (25) News - Railway Employee (25) News - Dearness Allowance (24) Station Master (24) TATKAL TICKET (22) RPF / RPSF (21) Railway News - Metro (20) Complaint and Suggestions (19) Rail News - Security (19) Railway Pensioners (19) Mumbai local (18) News - Catering (18) News - Job - Career (18) Rail News - Special Train (18) Railway time table (17) News - New Tech (16) ‘Premium’ Special Trains (15) Circulars - Govt of India (14) Know About (14) Rail News - Railway Revenue (14) Rail news - Employment Notification (14) Railway News - Delhi Metro (14) Scam (14) Railway Joke (13) Railway Board (12) Catering Related Complaints (11) DIVISION - RAIPUR (11) Dedicated Freight Corridors (11) Freight Corridor (11) Rail News - Security (11) AISMA (9) News - Exam Result (9) Rail News - New Rail Line (9) Railway pass (9) Budget (8) DIVISION - Ambala (8) Employee News (8) Indian Railway History (8) PHOTO (8) Passenger Amenities (8) Premium Air-Conditioned (8) World Rail - China (8) fares hikes (8) semi-high speed (8) Central Railway (7) INCOME TAX (7) Night Duty Allowance (7) Rail Accidents (7) Rail budget (7) online tickets (7) International Railway (6) Mono Rail (6) Mumbai Metro (6) News - Budget (6) Public Grievances (6) Rail Fares (6) Railway Safety (6) Ticket Booking (6) World Rail - Japan (6) Zone - Western Railway (6) extra coaches (6) guard (6) Always Important (5) Drinking Water (5) HELP (5) Holiday Trains (5) IRCON (5) LOCOMOTIVE (5) booking counters (5) hi-tech (5) macp (5) AIR - RAIL (4) Coaches (4) Food plazas (4) IMPORTANT RULE (4) Mumbai (4) News - Railway Rule (4) RAIL TEL (4) Rail History (4) Rail Neer (4) Rail News - Business (4) Rail News - Rules (4) Railway Minister (4) Train Cancellation (4) World Rail - Pakistan (4) Zone - South Central Railway (4) e-ticket booking (4) escalators (4) Booking - Parcel (3) CCTV (3) Children Education Allowance (3) DOUBLE DECKER TRAIN (3) Electrification (3) Konkan railway (3) Medical Allowance (3) Member Engineering (3) Modal Question Paper (3) News- Railway Exam (3) PASS (3) Question Bank (3) Rail News - China (3) Rail fare hike (3) Suvidha Train (3) TRANSFER POLICY (3) VAISHNO DEVI (3) new pension scheme (3) reservation (3) tatkal ticket (3) Booking - Luggage (2) D & A RULE (2) Extension of train services (2) Khumbn Mela (2) LDCE (2) Leave Rule (2) MATHERAN (2) MOBILE APPS (2) Minister of State for Railways (2) National Rail Museum (2) News - Rail Road (2) News -World Film (2) OROP (2) Passenger Reservation System (2) Police help desk (2) Provident Fund interest (2) Rail News - Goods Train (2) Railway Protection Force (2) Railway Proud (2) Railway Stations (2) Retiring Rooms (2) Revenue earnings (2) South Eastern Railway (2) Zone - East Central Railway (2) Zone - N E RLY (2) Zone - Northern Railway (2) Zone - Southern Railway (2) ALER (1) Air Travel (1) DIVISION - CENTRAL RAILWAY (1) DIVISION - MADURAI (1) DIVISION - VIJAYWADA (1) Directory (1) Division - Rangia (1) FOOT OVER BRIDGE (1) FORMS (1) Government Railway Police (1) House Rent Allowance (1) Interesting Facts (1) JAIPUR (1) LARGESS (1) LONDON (1) Lifeline Express (1) MST (1) Measures Against Fire (1) Medical Care (1) Ministry of Railway (1) News - TV (1) Passenger Security (1) RDSO (1) Rail - Roko (1) Rail Bridges (1) Rail News - Privatization (1) Rail News - Bengali (1) Rail News - Consumer Forum (1) Rail Tariff (1) Rail Tenders (1) Rail e-tickets (1) Railway Act (1) Railway Quarter (1) Railway Week (1) Rath Yatra (1) Road over Bridges work (1) SCRA (1) SKY BUS (1) Sainagar Shirdi (1) Suburban trains (1) Swadeshi (1) TRAVELLING ALLOWANCE (1) Ticket Examiner Staff (1) Track Man (1) WhatsApp (1) World Rail - New York (1) World Rail - Russia (1) World Rail - USA (1) World Rail - Washington (1) Zone - E RLY (1) Zone - N C RLY (1) Zone - North Western Railway (1) Zone - Northeast Frontier Railway (1) Zone - S E Railway (1) fire-fighting equipment (1) mobile ticket booking (1) railway station (1) smart card (1) wagon factories (1)

7th Pay Commission & Employee News Center